Android smartwatch app automatically saving songs without me saying to

[kr16]

Plan

Premium

Country

USA

Device

Samsung Gear Active Smartwatch

My Question or Issue

I'm listening to music on my watch using Wifi, not on offline mode, and with the "Download" option in my library turned off. Yet, every time I listen to a song and pull up the shuffle/skip/etc menu, the "Save" option is already automatically selected. I don't want every song I listen to to be automatically saved and I don't see anything in the settings to get it to stop.