Playing the wrong song?

[waitwhatever]

So when I try to play "Jesus of Suburbia" (the musical version) from the American Idiot Broadway Cast Album from my computer it instead plays "Jesus of Suburbia" from American Idiot, the original song from the original album by Green Day. The rest of the Broadway album is unaffected. This does not occur on my phone, and if I switch listening devices in the middle of the song, it will go back and forth, playing the Broadway version when I play it on my phone, and picking up at the same spot on the original when I switch back to my computer. 

Any thoughts? Could this be a problem on Spotify's end?

Edit: I just realized I posted this on the wrong board; I'm on a mac